cigarettes vs vaping thats the wrong comparison

The Last Days of Heroin: Fentanyl's Rise and the P... Five years ago, British Columbia saw a change. But much more evidence is needed to determine if they are an effective way to quit. I always say that was the wrong comparison to begin with. These are all chemicals that we know are toxic when inhaled. Q: You argue that people jumped the gun in terms of thinking that e-cigarettes are safer than regular cigarettes. I always say that was the wrong comparison to begin with. The similarity is that the behavior is very similar, and you can include nicotine in your vape; the similar behavior is why vaping is so much more effective for smoking cessation than any other product ever developed. Share via Email. It is an editorially independent program of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation which is not affiliated with Kaiser Permanente. We know they cause irritation. How is it different from previous versions of e-cigarettes? She had been following cases of patients with symptoms similar to those seen in the outbreak through academic articles since 2016. There isn’t really — at least not to my knowledge — any consumer product that if used according to its instructions is more toxic than cigarettes. There isn't really — at least not to my knowledge — any consumer product that if used according to its instructions is more toxic than cigarettes. Keep an open mind to things that are unexpected. Print. Tarthat eventually forms a sticky mass in the lungs 4. Q: You argue that people jumped the gun in terms of thinking that e-cigarettes are safer than regular cigarettes. When you think about cigarettes, you are looking at the inhalation of a mixture that’s caused by combusting tobacco plants and other chemicals within. Because we know they're very different from the get-go. Vaping and E-Cigarettes vs. smoking. Carmen Heredia Rodriguez of Kaiser Health News recently spoke with Jaspers about her research. Two recent studies shed some light on how they compare to traditional cigarette smoking and their own set of risks. So finding something that is more unsafe than cigarettes I think would be hard to do just because of where we are with the toxicity of cigarettes. So, all of this is highlighting a bigger problem that none of this is truly rigorously regulated. We know they cause toxicity. Many cigarettes also have various chemical additives which alter the flavor, make the nicotine more addictive… There are certain flavoring compounds that should never be contained in any e-liquid. This is where it gets a little complicated. Q: You talked about how some of the ingredients in e-liquids can turn into toxic chemicals when vaped. Smoking cigarettes is very different from vaping. That's propylene glycol and vegetable glycerin. They Juul. That’s propylene glycol and vegetable glycerin. So, let’s back up. It's not going to be that simple. Just because it's not there in the base liquid doesn't mean your lungs will not eventually be exposed to it. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. People got caught off guard here. Most cigarettes have a filter on the end made of cellulose acetate, which is biodegradable. So finding something that is more unsafe than cigarettes I think would be hard to do just because of where we are with the toxicity of cigarettes. It’s unfortunate that it took this outbreak to really highlight that problem, but it’s expediting the studies and hopefully some regulation. As an inhalation toxicologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Jaspers has for nearly 20 years studied the health effects of many substances that can be inhaled. So, they reduced the pH to something that’s much more neutral — much more tolerable to someone who’s never been a smoker. It’s not going to be that simple. Here, several aspects regarding the two habits smoking vs. vaping will be discussed to help you understand how they are similar or different. What Juul did is basically use a nicotine salt in a form of benzoic acid. We know they’re dangerous. Possibly. Katy. Is the difference in the way THC is consumed part of the problem? Q: Many of the lung injuries being reported by federal health officials have been associated with people who were vaping THC, the psychoactive ingredient in marijuana. Q: Do you agree with some federal and state officials who are calling for a ban on vaping products? The researchers couldn’t compare the others because they weren’t even detected in e-cigarette vapor. For Jaspers, who has two children, that was a "game changer. How is it different from previous versions of e-cigarettes? Seven of those years involved researching e-cigarettes. We know they're dangerous. Her academic detachment shattered, however, this summer when she received word about the first vaping-related death. The vast majority of these vaping products contain what we refer to as base compounds. Carbon monoxidewhich reduces the amount of oxygen carried by the red blood cells. That’s actually very irritating to the back of your throat. What was not done in the beginning was actually backing up the statement that [vaping products] are safe — or safer —  with real controlled studies. Q: Do you agree with some federal and state officials who are calling for a ban on vaping products? This transcript has been edited for length and clarity. Since then, Jaspers has written an editorial about potential dangers associated with vaping. Taking recreational drugs when you are on a course of antidepressants can cause comedowns, anxiety and muscle spasms. Carmen Heredia Rodriguez, Kaiser Health News. This transcript has been edited for length and clarity. E-cigarettes are probably the more visible of the two ways of vaping. THIS WEBSITE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE. Jump to Comments. When you think about cigarettes, you are looking at the inhalation of a mixture that's caused by combusting tobacco plants and other chemicals within. Her academic detachment shattered, however, this summer when she received word about the first vaping-related death. Because we know they’re very different from the get-go. They should not be allowed in any e-cigarette, in any flavored vaping device or vaping product. If there’s a new something out there, really take a careful look at it. A Q&A on the comparative dangers of smoking and vaping. Q: The e-cigarette Juul has gotten a lot of scrutiny in part because of its popularity among youth. The results so far are very encouraging. In other words, people can become addicted to vaping just as they can to smoking cigarettes. However, they do not contain tobacco. That's actually very irritating to the back of your throat. Because that's not the language they use. When you ask a 16-year-old who uses Juul, "Do you use nicotine or tobacco products," they're going to say, "No." Period. Would you compare cigarettes to smoking crack? Since then, Jaspers has written an editorial about potential dangers associated with vaping. Vaping: That’s The ‘Wrong Comparison,’ Says Inhalation Researcher Ilona Jaspers, an inhalation toxicologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, believes the common notion of comparing e-cigarettes with traditional, combustible cigarettes is the wrong analogy because the vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way. By definition, that's a very different exposure. The tobacco is blended to give the cigarettes a fairly consistent taste, as specific tobacco crops have different flavors depending on growing conditions. Not According to Science. Since then, Jaspers has written an editorial about potential dangers associated with vaping. By definition, that’s a very different exposure. When you vape, you should be vaping constantly or at least as much as you can or feel like you want to during the day. This transcript has been edited for length and clarity. Keep an open mind to things that are unexpected. This is where it gets a little complicated. But you note in your recent editorial that traditional marijuana has not led to any of these injuries. Q: What are the lessons that can be learned by the scientific community and society at large about this outbreak? Vaping Vs Smoking – How Do They Compare? Seven of She believes the common notion of comparing e-cigarettes with traditional, combustible cigarettes is an off-kilter analogy because the vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way. Q: What are the lessons that can be learned by the scientific community and society at large about this outbreak? For instance, in vaping the primary ingredients are nicotine, solvents, and flavorings. Ilona Jaspers initially approached the outbreak of vaping-related illnesses with a clinical curiosity. No, we don’t. She believes the common notion of comparing e-cigarettes with traditional, combustible cigarettes is an off-kilter analogy because the vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way. These are all chemicals that we know are toxic when inhaled. "It was just a little bit personal.". E-cigarettes are as addictive as regular smoking, thanks to the nicotine in them. She believes the common notion of comparing e-cigarettes with traditional, combustible cigarettes is an off-kilter analogy because the vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way. For acetaldehyde the figures are 0.8 to 1.5 μg for e-cigarettes and a huge 144 to 168 μg, and for acrolein the vaping device emitted 0.3 to 0.4 μg, whereas the heat-not-burn device released 10.4 to 10.8 μg. Cigarettes are the most toxic consumer product available, but vaping isn't necessarily a solution. Carmen Heredia Rodriguez of Kaiser Health News recently spoke with Jaspers about her research. To draw a proper comparison between a vaping device and cigarette in terms of puffs/drags would be impractical, near impossible even. And when that’s heated to a certain temperature, it actually forms things like acrolein, formaldehyde, acid aldehydes. Just because it’s not there in the base liquid doesn’t mean your lungs will not eventually be exposed to it. People got caught off guard here. Vaping is still pretty new to the market, only having been around for about a decade or so. In a review last year, Public Health England found that vaping is 95% less harmful than smoking conventional cigarettes and was helping 20,000 … This transcript has been edited for length and clarity. There are certain flavoring compounds that should never be contained in any e-liquid. This is because there are fewer chemicals which are found in e-cigarettes than in cigarettes. Clayre Barkema, Writer March 27, 2017. This is then inhaled, delivering nicotine to the body. Ilona Jaspers initially approached the outbreak of vaping-related illnesses with a clinical curiosity. But here’s what we do know. J... Drug And Alcohol Treatment Centers - Join Today ». … As an inhalation toxicologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Young Transplant Patient Thriving After Journey Through COVID-19 Pandemic to a New Heart, Safety Makes Even Stronger Demands on Construction During Pandemic, Central Florida Daily COVID-19 Update and ICU Availability, Moderna Ships Doses of Variant Specific Vaccine to NIH for Testing. Health comparison of e-cigarettes vs smoking. This transcript has been edited for length and clarity. Ever since they were first introduced in 2006, E-Cigarettes have been marketed to the smoking population as a safer, healthier alternative to smoking. Share on Facebook . “It was just a little bit personal.”. But we need to get this [outbreak] under control first. Since it hasnt been part of the public as much as cigarette smoking, theres a lot that people dont know about it. Since e-cigs contain nicotine derived from tobacco, the Food and Drug Administration announced a rule in 2016 that makes it so all electronic cigarettes are subject to government regulation, as is the case with cigarettes. Vaping is the inhalation and exhalation of aerosol from an e-cigarette. Vaping is less harmful than traditional smoking. And when that's heated to a certain temperature, it actually forms things like acrolein, formaldehyde, acid aldehydes. Nicotinewhich is absorbed in the brain within the first six seconds after inhalation. Kaiser Health News (KHN) is a national health policy news service. Graphic by Clayre Barkema. While e-cigarettes or vaping has grown in popularity over the last several years, there is still a lot unknowns surrounding their long-term health effects. While it’s true tha… The vast majority of these vaping products contain what we refer to as base compounds. So, they reduced the pH to something that's much more neutral — much more tolerable to someone who's never been a smoker. On the other hand, cigarettes contain over 7000 chemicals, most of which are toxic harmful to your health. She believes the common notion of comparing e-cigarettes with traditional, combustible cigarettes is an off-kilter analogy because the vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way. Q: The e-cigarette Juul has gotten a lot of scrutiny in part because of its popularity among youth. So, you can only take in a limited amount. She believes the common notion of comparing e-cigarettes with traditional, combustible cigarettes is an off-kilter analogy because the vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way. They also ruled that e-cig purchasers must be at least 18 years old. She had been following cases of patients with symptoms similar to those seen in the outbreak through academic articles since 2016. Regular nicotine in a cigarette comes in the form of free base. Feb 05, 2021 at 10:36 am by Q: Many of the lung injuries being reported by federal health officials have been associated with people who were vaping THC, the psychoactive ingredient in marijuana. As an inhalation toxicologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Jaspers has for nearly 20 years studied the health effects of many substances that can be inhaled. Juul found a way to make the nicotine much more palatable and, as a consequence, they jacked up the nicotine concentration. Whereas in e-cigarettes, you are aerosolizing in a liquid. I think some of the things that are now under review are these sort of bootlegged THC products that probably have contaminants in there like vitamin E and some other oils and maybe even pesticides. (Courtesy of the UNC Gillings School of Global Public Health). The other thing is that we need to educate all of our health care providers to ask the right questions. Smoking involves the burning of tobacco which produces smoke containing nicotine. It’s not going to be one chemical causing all of these hospitalizations. A single stick of cigarette contains over four thousand chemicals, 400 of which are toxic, including 43 known carcinogens. As an inhalation toxicologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Jaspers has for nearly 20 years studied the health effects of many substances that can be inhaled. The information contained on this website is not intended to be a substitute for, or to be relied upon as, medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Juul found a way to make the nicotine much more palatable and, as a consequence, they jacked up the nicotine concentration. Vaping is still relatively new so there’s a lot that we don’t know yet about the risks. Period. Much is still unknown about e-cigarettes, especially in the long-term. Ilona Jaspers initially approached the outbreak of vaping-related illnesses with a clinical curiosity. We know they cause irritation. Possibly. Cigarettes vs Vaping the'Wrong Comparison,' Researcher Says Cigarettes vs Vaping the'Wrong Comparison,' Researcher Says An inhalation toxicologist believes e-cigarettes should not be compared with traditional, combustible cigarettes because vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way.Kaiser Health News What Juul did is basically use a nicotine salt in a form of benzoic acid. They Juul. With cigarettes, you get the urge to smoke one because you feel like you “need it.” With vaping, you should be doing it periodically, so that you can keep the nicotine in your system and not feel that urge. For Jaspers, who has two children, that was a “game changer.”, “It’s different when you sort of read about it in the literature and in a more anonymized way rather than seeing [teens on respirators] on TV,” she said. Is the difference in the way THC is consumed part of the problem? Prolonged use of nicotine affects the heart, arteries, and lungs. This website is for informational purposes only. So, all of this is highlighting a bigger problem that none of this is truly rigorously regulated. 2. If there's a new something out there, really take a careful look at it. Cigarettes vs. Vaping: ‘Wrong comparison,’ says toxicologist. E-cigarettes. So, let's back up. Cigarettes Vs. Vaping: That's The 'Wrong Comparison,' Says Inhalation Researcher Vaping: That's The 'Wrong Comparison,' Says Inhalation Researcher by Carmen Heredia Rodriguez Nov 05, 2019 at 02:25 pm by pj. Carmen Heredia Rodriguez of Kaiser Health News recently spoke with Jaspers about her research. Ilona Jaspers initially approached the outbreak of vaping-related illnesses with a clinical curiosity. So, you can only take in a limited amount. AP PHOTO. The other thing is that we need to educate all of our health care providers to ask the right questions. Carmen Heredia Rodriguez of Kaiser Health News recently spoke with Jaspers about her research. Finding Drug and Alcohol Treatment Centers is easy by searching our trusted network of top-rated Drug and Alcohol Treatment Centers. ", "It's different when you sort of read about it in the literature and in a more anonymized way rather than seeing [teens on respirators] on TV," she said. Photo of Ilona Jaspers. It’s Time to Get Back to Normal? Are they wrong and why? What was not done in the beginning was actually backing up the statement that [vaping products] are safe — or safer — with real controlled studies. Share on Twitter. Harmful ingredients in a cigarette include: 1. No doubt, the best option for any smoker is to quit tobacco and nicotine use altogether. Are they wrong and why? But you note in your recent editorial that traditional marijuana has not led to any of these injuries. By contrast, vaping heats up an e-liquid (often containing nicotine) which is vapourised and inhaled by the user. Regular nicotine in a cigarette comes in the form of free base. Vaping: That's The 'Wrong Comparison,' Says Inhalation Researcher As an inhalation toxicologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Jaspers has for nearly 20 years studied the health effects of many substances that can be inhaled. It's not going to be one chemical causing all of these hospitalizations. Disclaimer: But we need to get this [outbreak] under control first. Carmen Heredia Rodriguez of Kaiser Health News recently spoke with Jaspers about her research. When you ask a 16-year-old who uses Juul, “Do you use nicotine or tobacco products,” they’re going to say, “No.” Because that’s not the language they use. Cigarettes Versus Vaping Is ‘Wrong Comparison,’ Says Researcher . Cancer Research UK has been doing a lot of research in comparing traditional smoking vs e-cigarettes. We know they cause toxicity. Seven of those years involved researching e-cigarettes. Cigarettes Vs. Vaping: That’s The ‘Wrong Comparison,’ Says Inhalation Researcher. Q: You talked about how some of the ingredients in e-liquids can turn into toxic chemicals when vaped. Would you compare cigarettes to smoking crack? No, we don't. E-cigarette promoters claim the devices can help people quit smoking. 3. They should not be allowed in any e-cigarette, in any flavored vaping device or vaping product. Ilona Jaspers initially approached the outbreak of vaping-related illnesses with a clinical curiosity. I think some of the things that are now under review are these sort of bootlegged THC products that probably have contaminants in there like vitamin E and some other oils and maybe even pesticides. Whereas in e-cigarettes, you are aerosolizing in a liquid. They include products produced by major brands like Blu, Juul, and Logic. She believes the common notion of comparing e-cigarettes with traditional, combustible cigarettes is an off-kilter analogy because the vaping products expose consumers to chemicals in a fundamentally different way. Many people think vaping is less harmful than smoking. Arsenicwhich is associated with skin and lung cancer 5. The appearance of the first e-cigarette was back in 2007, and since then the popularity of vaping has increased immensely. There’s no correlation between a cigarette and a vaping device in regards to form and means of ingested nicotine. This story was produced by Kaiser Health News, an editorially independent program of the Kaiser Family Foundation. Traditional cigarettes are rolled into a paper and are filled with a blend of tobacco. As an inhalation toxicologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Jaspers has for nearly 20 years studied the health effects of many substances that can be inhaled. Research suggests that users are more likely to continue smoking along with vaping, which is referred to as “dual use.” The American Heart Association recommends proven methods to successfully quit smoking. Carmen Heredia Rodriguez: CarmenH@kff.org, @ByCHRodriguez, Related Topics Insight Public Health Study Tobacco Vaping. What are those chemicals? What are those chemicals? It's unfortunate that it took this outbreak to really highlight that problem, but it's expediting the studies and hopefully some regulation.

Roblox Skirt Id, Did The Red Lotus Kill Aang, Homes For Sale Brevard County Florida Zillow, Victorian Sword Cane, 1998 Ford E-250 Van Specs, Best Brightness Settings For Warzone Ps4,